Happy Hacking Professional 2 Keyboard Review
Jan 10th, 2007 by Q
|
Last month I bought the PFU Happy Hacking Professional 2 keyboard. Buying a keyboard this expensive is no small decision, but after trying out dozens of top-rated keyboards from Shinjuku to Akihabara I became resolved that it was undeniably the best keyboard on the market. I do a lot of typing. The impetus for buying the keyboard last month was a contract job I received (that I’m taking a break from now as I write this) which requires an immense volume of typing. In the last five weeks I’ve typed out more than 350 pages of text for this job. So a comfortably keyboard was essential. Normal keyboards work based on a membrane dome under each key, and while they are quiet, they feel rather mushy and don’t last long under extended use. I would always feel that the keys started getting sticky after a few months of use. A couple years ago I started using a mechanical-switch keyboard from FILCO that cost about $50. That seemed like a lot for a keyboard at the time, but I found that I could type more efficiently on it, and it was much more durable than a membrane keyboard. The downside to this keyboard was that it was quite loud, to the point that my wife couldn’t talk on the phone in the same room I was typing in. This fall my FILCO was starting get sluggish, as even mechanical keyboards start to suffer from sticky springs after extended use. I went down to a keyboard specialty shop in a back alley of Akihabara where more than a hundred keyboards of various manufacturers and styles were laid out for testing. I was at first drawn to the oddly shaped ergonomic keyboards, as my wrists and hands do start to hurt after several hours of typing, despite the wrist-rest that I use. Unfortunately, the ergonomic keyboards were all membrane based, so matter how comfortable your wrists might be while typing, the reflex-action of the keys was quite poor. After trying out just about every keyboard in that store and several others, the conclusion was clear. The small but surprisingly expensive HHKB2 had far and above the best key action. The best way that I can explain the superiority of the HHKB2 is by the fact that after typing on it for a while, any other keyboard that you type on seems inferior and somewhat annoying to use. The HHKB2 is very compact and lacks the Backspace, Caps Lock, Function Keys, and arrow keys. But there is a Fn key so that you can get the same results and through holding down the Fn key you get virtual arrow keys. I wanted a Backspace key so I used KeyTweak to change the left bracket, which I never use, into the backspace. This places the backspace just to the right of the ] making it very easy to reach without moving my hand. (FEB 2009 UPDATE: I am no longer using the left bracket in this manner. I just use the Delete key as a backspace, it’s one of the default options that can be changed on the keyboard.) Since I’m using it as a second keyboard for my Japanese laptop, I use USJP Pro v1.2.5 to allow me to use the HHKB2 as an English-layout keyboard and still keep my laptop’s keyboard as a Japanese keyboard. The only downsides for me is that I was so used to Japanese keyboard layout that I’m still adjusting to the locations of a couple keys that are different between English and Japanese keyboards, and the fact that the key used to switch from English to Japanese input is an Alt tilde, which is slower than just hitting one key next to the spacebar. Still, I can do it pretty quickly now so it’s not too bad. After five weeks of use I’m very pleased with the HHKB2. The only thing that I can think of that might be superior would be an ergonomically designed keyboard with keys of this quality. Typing really is a joy with this keyboard, if you can imagine that, and my speed has increased to a steady 90 to 100 words per minute from my previous 80. The model that I bought is the same as the one shown in the photo above, but the more popular models have blank keys. I can definitely see the geek pride-value in using one of these, but I opted for labeled keys as I’m still getting used to the location of some characters on the English Keyboard. PFU is a Fujitsu Company. The HHKB2 has an English website here. FEBRUARY 2009 UPDATE: After using this keyboard excessively every single day of the last two plus years, they key action is still just about as good as the day I bought it. I burned through normal keyboards about every six months with my constant typing and mechanical keyboards got sluggish or sticky after a year. I could not be happier with the Happy Hacking Professional 2. If you’re outside of Japan you can buy it at smartimports.net here. |

Great review! Want to get one, but having a hard time deciding between the Lite and Pro versions. How quiet are the keys on the Pro? How much difference in feel is there between the Lite’s membrane keys and the Pro’s spring keys? Any other major differences you noticed (aside from the obvious layout change)?
The keys on the pro are a little on the loud side, though nowhere near as loud as some FILCO mechanical keyboards that I’ve used previously. (When I need to be quiet I an intentionally type softly and make less noise, but when I’m going full throttle then it is a little louder.)
I only tried out the Lite at the store, but it was no comparison to the Pro. I wasn’t at all impressed with the Lite. I would say a $50 mechanical keyboard would be better if you’re on a budget. Since I only tried out the Lite briefly, I can’t comment on changes or other differences.
Thank you for writing your review! I was debating over the HHK Pro v. Lite2, but I think I will go with the pro model now. I was looking for a good tiny sized keyboard, and there are tons out there with the laptop key look. I’m learning Dvorak, so the blank pro model will force my touch typing habits (I speed type with three fingers on a QWERTY keyboard)(lol). I think though, one would choose the Pro over the Lite2 to have the benefits of a solidly built piece of machinery. Yeah it sounds geeky, but we have these new Gateways at our campus with horrible plastic keyboards that have very little substance to them. You had to smash them down and they were just plain uncomfortable! They changed them just as we were getting into finals and I noticed my typing speed slowed down. No thank you! I’ll get a quality keyboard to call my own, pop it in my backpack, and use it in place of the crapo boards. lol
I’ve heard you need to keep the Fn key depressed to use arrow keys. Is it difficult to get the hang of it? Thanks for pointing out the KeyTweak program. I think I will get a USB numbered keypad and try and turn it into a set of arrow keys along side the HHK Pro
Cheers!
-Ren =^.^=
The Fn Key arrows aren’t bad once you get used to them. Now that I’ve been using this keyboard for about six months now and I’m pretty quick with the simulated arrows. That does sound like a good idea to get an extra keypad if you have the room.
I’m heading down to Akihabara to get one of these. Is there a best place to look or are these available all over?
Cheers!
Howdy.
Ended up here via a google search on keyboard technology.
I have a special place in my heart for quality keyboards, and enjoyed your review of the HHKB Pro 2. I actually spent some time these past couple of weeks trying to find a decent online community dedicated to keyboard enthusiasts…however, I was unsuccessful. So, I set up a forum of my own. http://geekhack.org
Feel free to stop by. There DO seem to be some good blogs out there (like this one), so I may setup a user blog section and import RSS feeds…allowing users to get more exposure for their sites.
Since you like the HHKB Pro line, I figured you might in interested in a contest I am cooking up to help launch the site. Basically, my idea is to have people submit an essay to the forum detailing why I should give them a free Happy Hacking Professional (blank) keyboard. I DO have one to give away and figure that might be a good way to increase awareness of the site’s existence (of course, it might also get me slashdot’ed).
Anyways, again, great blog. I am enjoying reading through the archives.
[...] Originally Posted by thiru I don't know if there are even Swedish keyboards with reds, so you'll have to go with that brown Filco. But I think the Topre Realforce is even lighter, and there's one here: http://www.keyboardco.com/keyboard_d…sp?PRODUCT=793 Technically they're lighter, but I've never used them and they're expensive as hell. Great tip, thanks. Apparently it uses the same keys as the guy who wrote http://www.fz.se/artiklar/hardvara/2…lco-majestouch uses. HE describes the happy hacker kb as his holy grale of keyboards http://quinlanfaris.com/?p=69. [...]